Diets come in many shapes and sizes, and the key to choosing the right one for your body depends not only on the actual diet plan but also on how feasible it is for you to maintain long-term.
While some diets become popular fads, that does not mean that the diet will be practical or effective.
Many eating plans also have similarities, which can make it confusing to know which ones will be a good choice.
How do you choose between similar options? Those looking for a new eating plan will point out the likeness between South Beach Diet vs keto.
By understanding each of these plans and their distinct pros and cons, you can determine which of them could change your overall health for the better.
All About South Beach Diet
The South Beach Diet became popular in the early 2000s, and it has remained a popular eating plan for those looking to have a healthier lifestyle.
Like keto, this plan focuses on helping the body get into fat-burning mode, but the method of doing so differs from that of a strictly keto diet.
What Is the South Beach Diet?
The South Beach Diet uses a tiered system and a good-bad qualification system to help dieters plan their meals and start losing weight quickly.
In the first two weeks of the diet, you cut all sugars, and most carbohydrates are off-limits to push the body into fat-burning mode and reduce dependence on those items.
Many individuals who follow the diet lose up to 12 pounds during that phase, and there may even be some cardiovascular benefits.
After that initial phase, you can add some good carbohydrates back into the diet; the amount of weight lost weekly from that point will be less substantial but more sustainable.
Once dieters have lost as much weight as they desire, the idea is to transform your diet into a more liberal but easy-to-follow diet that is low in sugar and “bad” carbohydrates with lean cuts of meat to help maintain weight.
Though each phase of the diet includes a different eating plan, the overall idea still favors carbohydrates that do not spike blood sugar, as this can help keep energy levels consistent.
Additionally, all phases of the diet push healthy fats rather than processed or trans fats; this is very similar to how keto works.
There are also variations of the South Beach Diet that you can follow within the larger constraints of this type of eating plan.
There is even a keto-variation of South Beach Diet that you can follow, which makes sense since many of the eating-plan attributes overlap between the two.
South Beach Diet meals and meal plans can be purchased commercially, making it a very convenient choice for many people who are easily overwhelmed by the need to design their own eating plan.
Example Eating Plan
Below is an example of what you can eat during each phase of the South Beach Diet.
- Breakfast: Cooked omelet with ham and spinach; coffee
- Snack: Roasted chickpeas
- Lunch: Vegetable salad with shrimp or scallops
- Snack: Turkey roll-up
- Dinner: Grilled tuna with veggies and a salad
- Breakfast: Pear bran muffin
- Snack: One serving of low-sugar fruit
- Lunch: Chipotle-flavored steak wrap
- Snack: Turkey roll-up
- Dinner: Grilled tuna with a small amount of brown rice and corn
- Breakfast: Quiche with a slice of whole-grain bread
- Snack: Greek yogurt
- Lunch: Salad with grilled chicken or tuna; a small amount of dressing
- Snack: One serving of berries
- Dinner: Hearty grain like barley with a small portion of meat and veggies
Benefits of the South Beach Diet
- May improve cardiovascular health
- May help lower blood pressure
- Losing weight may help improve diabetes
- Turns into a healthy lifestyle rather than a diet by Phase 3
- Pre-made males can be bought through the plan
Potential Drawbacks of the South Beach Diet
- Phase 1 and 2 can be difficult to maintain
- Limits fat more than necessary
- Too restrictive for some people
- Can be expensive to buy the pre-made meal plans
All About Keto
Keto eating plans, which center on helping your body burn fat as efficiently as possible by eating in specific ways, have become more popular than ever in the last few years.
What Is Keto?
The basis of the keto diet is to reduce the number of carbohydrates consumed drastically; the ratio of good fats is increased to balance out the body’s needs.
All-in-all, the eating plan centers on consuming a high amount of fat, a moderate amount of protein, and a low amount of carbohydrates.
By eating in this fashion, the body may enter what is known as ketosis or the process of burning dietary and stored fat via metabolic changes.
The keto diet originated as a medical treatment for epilepsy many decades ago, but it is used today by people for various reasons.
The ultimate goal of all keto diet plans is to convince your body to use fat as the primary energy source.
While there is not one comprehensive keto plan you can purchase commercially, there are several businesses that market their own keto plans and meals that you can use if you would prefer to buy one.
Types of Keto Diets
People follow keto diets in different ways depending on what their nutritional needs and particular health goals are.
While the overall goal of the keto diet is always to consume meals with high fat, moderate protein, and low carbohydrate content, the exact breakdown of those macros will differ from person to person.
For some people, keto is a long-term change in their lifestyle, so they need to make sure it is manageable indefinitely.
For others, eating keto is a temporary change to kickstart their weight loss process, so the exact plan doesn’t need as much longevity.
The only factor that must remain is most daily calories come from the high amount of healthy fats in the diet, and that there are very few carbohydrates.
Without those two factors, the eating plan would not be keto, since it would not encourage ketosis.
Example Keto Eating Plan
- High amounts of full-fat dairy
- Fatty cuts of meat
- Nut butter
- No sugar
- Refined carbohydrates only, in limited amounts
- Only keto-friendly condiments
Below is an example of what someone following a keto health plan might eat in one day:
- Breakfast: Eggs scrambled in butter with lettuce and an avocado
- Snack: Nuts or seeds
- Lunch: High-fat burger on a lettuce wrap with avocado
- Snack: Jerky with no sugar
- Dinner: Chicken roasted with mushrooms and asparagus (or other non-starchy veggies)
Benefits of Keto
- Weight loss starts quickly
- Can help balance hormones
- Reduces acne in some followers
- May help manage diabetes long-term
- Feel less hungry than other diets due to high-fat intake
Potential Drawbacks of Keto
- “Keto flu” can make you feel off at first
- Puts a lot of stress on the liver
- Not good for those on blood sugar medications
- Easy to rely on processed foods; should try to avoid those
Key Similarities and Differences Between Keto and South Beach
Now that you have a better understanding of both diets, let’s highlight the key similarities and differences between the two plans to get a sense of what is going to fit best with your lifestyle.
- South Beach Diet meal plans and meals are available commercially, while keto is a more general diet term.
- You can follow both plans while prepping your own food from scratch.
- Both plans focus on reducing the number of trans and saturated fats in favor of high amounts of healthy fat.
- Keto does not have different phases, while the South Beach diet gets less restrictive over time.
- Both plans encourage your body to burn fat for energy.
- South Beach Diet is harder to follow at first but becomes easier.
- Both plans limit carbohydrate intake to some degree
- Both plans can help you learn healthier eating habits
- You should follow both plans with caution according to your personal nutritional needs.
As you can see, there are a lot of similarities between the two diets, but the nitty-gritty details of how both plans work differs a lot depending on which plan you are following.
South Beach Diet vs Keto: Which Is Better?
When it comes to deciding between South Beach Diet vs keto, this is not a simple, clear-cut way to choose a winner.
There are so many similarities between the two that a diet might easily fit in with the rules of both plans at the same time.
If your primary goal is up-front weight loss and you plan to figure out a long-term lifestyle change separate from your diet plan, using keto may be more effective as many find that they burn more weight on this plan.
If you want to buy a commercial meal plan that has the meals pre-made or pre-planned for you, the South Beach Diet will make the overall process well-organized and easy-to-follow for you.
Ultimately, both plans can be followed with success in terms of both losing weight and finding a healthier lifestyle than what you are currently living.